It was shortly after midnight when two Viet Cong commandos emerged from a sewer tunnel that emptied into Saigon Port, each man carrying nearly 90 pounds of high explosives and the components needed to make two time bombs.
Their target was the largest American ship in port, USNS Card – an escort carrier that saw distinguished service as a submarine-hunter in the North Atlantic during World War II. During the early morning hours of May 2, 1964, Card was part of U.S. Military Sealift Command.
The ship supported an escalating military commitment of the South Vietnamese government that occurred well before theTonkin Gulf Incident. Since 1961, Card had transported both fixed-wing aircraft and helicopters to the beleaguered nation as well as the U.S. pilots and support crews needed to operate them.
The commandos swam toward Card, where they spent about an hour in the water attaching the charges just above the waterline near the bilge and the engine compartment on the ship’s starboard side. They set the timers and quickly swam away.
The charges exploded. Five civilian crewmen on board Card died, the explosion tore a huge hole in the engine-room compartment and a proud ship that had survived German U-boat attacks was on her way to the bottom — the last aircraft carrier in U.S. military history to date sunk by enemy action.
USNS ‘Card’ in Saigon port after the attack
The sinking of the Card was stunning victory for the Viet Cong, yet little remembered today. It illustrated how vulnerable naval vessels can be even when faced with a low-tech enemy … and how difficult maintaining port security can be in a war with no real front.
But it also demonstrated how resilient American naval forces are. In 17 days, salvage crews raised Card out of nearly 50 feet of water, and six months later the ship returned to service for another six years. Not surprisingly, North Vietnam celebrated the sinking of Card, considering it a propaganda victory of the first rank. The U.S. government refused to even acknowledge the vessel’s sinking, telling the public the carrier had only been damaged.
The North Vietnamese government even commemorated the event by portraying the operation on a 1964 postage stamp.
Naval vessels often have a mystique about them — they look formidable, bristle with weapons and aircraft, and have the ability to project a nation’s power anywhere on the planet. In particular, aircraft carriers are the symbol of a nation possessing “great power” status.
But they are vulnerable to attack. For example, there are reasons why even aircraft carriers have numerous escort vessels — destroyers, guided-missile cruisers, even submarines — to protect a carrier as well as engage the enemy.
We shouldn’t be too surprised when an enemy takes out a naval vessel in combat, even if it is a commando with a time bomb, James Holmes, a naval historian and analyst who teaches at the U.S. Naval War College, told War Is Boring.
“We shouldn’t get carried away with thinking of warships as ‘castles of steel,’ or latter-day dreadnoughts, or whatever,” Holmes said. “A castle is a fortification whose walls can take enormous punishment, whereas most modern warships have thin sides — the nuclear-powered carrier being an honorable exception. So a guy with a charge can do a lot of damage.”
Holmes said the sinking of Card “provided a preview” of the attack on the USS Cole in 2000 — a textbook case of a low-tech assault taking out a prime example of U.S. naval might.
Damage to the USS ‘Cole’ after an Al Qaeda attack in 2000. US Navy photo
Al Qaeda operatives mounted a suicide attack against Cole, a guided-missile destroyer, using a small boat packed with explosives that targeted the American ship while she was docked in Aden harbor. The blast tore a huge hole in the vessel, killing 17 sailors and injuring 39 — the deadliest attack on a U.S. Navy ship in recent history.
The blast from the explosion reached Cole’s galley, killing and wounding many there as sailors were lining up for lunch. Investigators later said they did not consider the timing of the attack a coincidence.
Fifty years ago, penetrating harbor security was a major concern as well for the perpetrators of the attack on Card.
Lam Son Nao, 79, the leader of the Viet Cong commandos, was a maintenance worker at the port at the time of the attack. He used his job as cover while he gathered intelligence, hid explosives and planned the mission.
Despite patrol boats filled with harbor police, Nao and his companion were able to mount their operation because of careful planning and the corruption of Saigon law enforcement.
“For the Card mission, my fellow operative and I pretended to be fishermen,” Nao said in an April 22, 2015 interview with Vietnamese News Service. “When our boat reached Nha Rong Wharf, the police chased us to the bank of the Thu Thiem Peninsula. To avoid having my boat inspected, we pushed the boat to a swamp, so that the police boat could not reach it.”
Nao told the harbor police that he wanted to shop at a market on a nearby island, offering to share part of the clothing and radios he planned to buy there. Then, he gave the police a generous bribe — and they let Nao go his way.
The aftermath of the attack on the Card rallied American rescue and salvage crews to deal with a severe crisis. The American brass and Pres. Lyndon Johnson wanted to keep the results of the attack as quiet as possible.
However, raising Card would be a major salvage operation.
Five Navy divers investigated damage to Card. One said he found the remains of a U.S.-made demolitions pack — evidence that the Viet Cong might have used stolen American military munitions.
In the meantime, the Navy sent the salvage vessel USS Reclaimer and the tug USS Tawakoni to Saigon Port to begin pumping water out of the sunken vessel. Despite poor diving conditions and numerous equipment malfunctions, salvage crews raised Card in a little more than two weeks.
Soon, both Reclaimer and Tawakoni towed Card out of Saigon harbor on their way to the U.S. Navy port of Subic Bay in the Philippines for repairs.
Naval vessels are very flexible ships capable of recuperating from serious battle damage. Apparently, Card was no exception — ships are often “re-purposed” in the U.S. Navy and enjoy long lives in service, Holmes said.
“The carrier Midway went from being a World War II carrier to a modern supercarrier over the course of her life, which reached into the 1990s,” he said. “That philosophy — deliberately build ships to allow for easy changes and upgrades over a long life — is making a comeback.”
Even Cole survived her attackers. After 14 months of repair, Cole departed dry-dock on April 19, 2002, and returned to her homeport of Norfolk, Virginia.
The ship deployed again in 2003. Cole remains in operation with the Sixth Fleet. Card decommissioned in 1970.
This first appeared in WarIsBoring on July 23, 2017 by Paul Richard Huard here.
SPECIAL NOTE: She was decommissioned after war in 1946, and laid in reserve until 1958, when she was reactivated for the Military Sea Transportation Service as an aircraft transport (T-CVU-11, and later T-AKV-40), the predecessor of today’s Military Sealift Command. Ships like the Card were owned by the Navy (hence the USNS designation) but staffed by civilian crews, which is how Merchant Mariners like Capt. Langeland came to be in the Port of Saigon that fateful morning. Read more about it here: https://www.navalhistory.org/2015/10/07/the-attack-on-the-usns-card?fref=gc
Thank you for taking the time to read this. Should you have a question or comment about this article, then scroll down to the comment section below to leave your response.
If you want to learn more about the Vietnam War and its Warriors, then subscribe to this blog and get notified by email or your feed reader every time a new story, picture, video or changes occur on this website – the button is located at the top right of this page.
I’ve also created a poll to help identify my website audience – before leaving, can you please click HERE and choose the one item best describing you. Thank you in advance!
Enjoyed reading about a secret that was not released to the general publicity or the local papers. What a shame for the families of the Servce men who died that day..
LikeLiked by 1 person
So it was being used to haul cargo?
Another great story, Pdog biker, I’ll repost it on the museum site and point all credit back to you and your excellent site, you take care now,
Naples Museum of Military History
UM….First off your title says a carrier sank by NVA and the first picture you post is the USS Midway CV-41 and the last picture, after talking about the attack on the USS Cole by Al-Quieda terrorists, you say the Cole in 1944. Shouldn’t that be the Card or is that a different ship all together? Also according to several sources “On 2 May 1964, while moored dockside in Saigon, a North Vietnamese frogman, Lam Son Nao, planted an explosive charge that blew a hole in the hull, killing five crewmen. (It should be noted that this event was prior to the Gulf of Tonkin Incident which led to the escalation of American involvement in Vietnam.) Card settled in 20 feet (6.1 m) of water. She was patched and pumped out, and raised on 19 May, and towed to Subic Bay, and then Yokosuka for repairs. Card returned to service on 11 December.”
I made a living as salvage diver along Saigon port 5 years after the war, during the time of economic blockage, mostly pulling up anything usable off the bottom. I don’t think swimming bare hand with a 90lb load is possible, even if that the Card were not anchored in the middle of the river .
There were only two possibilities to deliver that load:
1/ pretend to act like the boat being drifted due to engine or oar failure. The Russian tanker sank my little boat in 1978 when I used that trick with diesel bomb as it was pumping to unload.
2/ attaching the load beneath a big batch of floating greens which is normal and abundant in tropical river.
I am bad enough to be still on their black list, and never heard of them celebrating this incident.
I was there in 69-70 and did not know this BAD News coverage
Outstanding. This was a new one to me!!
Greg “GW” Moore
Vietnam Class of 1970