Nearly fifty-four years ago, an Associated Press correspondent made a series of photographs that would shock a president and impact U.S. policy on the Vietnam War.
GRAPHIC WARNING: Contains images which some viewers may find disturbing.
AP Saigon correspondent Malcolm Browne interviews Quang Lien, leading spokesman for the Xa Loi Buddhist pagoda in Saigon, on June 27, 1963.
Malcolm Wilde Browne was 30 years old when he arrived in Saigon on Nov. 7, 1961, as AP’s first permanent correspondent there. From the start, Browne was filing the kind of big stories that would win him the Pulitzer Prize for reporting in 1964. But today, he is primarily remembered for a photograph taken 50 years ago on June 11, 1963, depicting the dignified yet horrific death by fiery suicide of Buddhist monk Thich Quang Duc.
Following years of growing tension, the Buddhist majority in South Vietnam reached its breaking point under the repressive regime of Catholic Ngo Dinh Diem. On May 8, 1963, in the ancient imperial capital of Hue, South Vietnamese soldiers opened fire on a group of Buddhists who were flying the Buddhist flag in direct violation of a government ban. Nine were killed.
In late May and early June, the Saigon Buddhists staged street demonstrations and memorial services for the victims of the May 8 incident. On June 1, two monks informed AP Saigon correspondent Malcolm Browne, along with other foreign correspondents, that two elderly monks planned to commit ritual suicide in protest against the Diem regime.
The story of how that happened began at 9 p.m. on June 10, 1963, when journalist Malcolm Wilde Browne received a cryptic message that something important would happen at a memorial service organized by Buddhist monks the next morning.
Mr. Browne, I strongly advise you to come. I expect something very important will happen, but I cannot tell you what.
Malcolm Browne / AP Buddhist monks pray at Xa Loi pagoda, on June 11, 1963, prior to staging a protest march against the government’s oppressive actions against Buddhists.
As day broke on June 11, the service started with nuns and monks chanting in the temple. After a while, the group moved onto the streets, chanting in a procession. The group paused to surround a car, and then took out a can of aviation fuel.
The monks and nuns filed into the street, and all began to move in the general direction of the Xa Loi Pagoda.
“I realized at that moment exactly what was happening, and began to take pictures a few seconds apart,” wrote Browne in a letter to AP General Manager Wes Gallagher on Sept. 30, 1963.
Malcolm Browne / AP Buddhist monk Thich Quang Duc is doused with gasoline during a demonstration in Saigon.
One of the monks sat down in the street, and fellow monks covered him in nearly five gallons of fuel. Moments later, Thich Quang Duc struck a match and set himself ablaze. It was then that Browne made the photo that left an indelible impression on people across the globe.
Malcolm Browne / AP Thich Quang Duc, a Buddhist monk, burns himself to death to protest alleged persecution of Buddhists by the South Vietnamese government. This is the photograph that is more widely known today.
A version of this image was the first published and was widely used in newspapers around the world. It was sent over the wire and used in papers worldwide a mere 15 hours after Thich Quang set himself on fire. The images journey in a pre-digital world, took a remarkable 15 hours over 9,000 miles of AP WirePhoto cable for Malcolm Browne’s Burning Monk to become breaking news. The photo compelled President John F. Kennedy to reassess U.S. policy on Vietnam, ultimately increasing the number of troops.
MONKS PRAY OVER QUANG DUC’S CHARRED BODY
`
MONKS WRAP QUANG DUC’S BODY IN THEIR ROBES AND BEGIN THE PROCESSION TO XA LOI PAGODA
Just as the new procession was getting under way, lots of other correspondents began arriving. … All of us accompanied the procession to Xa Loi Pagoda, a walk of about 10 minutes.
We were doing nothing more nor less than our jobs as newsmen.
As more pictures came into New York in succeeding days, the complete sequence became available. The picture that we now refer to as “The Ultimate Protest” was one of these. It shows Thich Quang Duc’s face and the fine drapery of his garments as he is engulfed in silvery tongues of flame. It is a shockingly beautiful image that immediately took on a life of its own, so that we no longer recall the first published image.
In many ways, “The Ultimate Protest” paved the way for the other iconic image of the war, taken by AP photographer Nick Ut in 1972, of a young girl wounded by a napalm strike and running in agony toward the photographer, her clothes burned off. By then, the world was used to this visual assault. It was also growing tired of the long war.
Browne would later recount that the monks at the protest had trouble getting Thich Quang Duc horribly burnt corpse into a casket, “because he was splayed out in all directions.” After the protest Duc’s body was burned again when his fellow monks cremated him. The monks claim that his body was reduced to ashes except for his heart which while singed was still intact. The organ was declared Holy and is still kept as a holy artifact by the monks. Before Duc died he composed a letter to explain his actions and asked people to unite and work towards the preservation of Buddhism in Vietnam and around the world. This became known as the Letter of Heart Blood.
The heart refused to burn after Thich Quang Duc was cremated
`
The car seen in the background has been saved and is still viewed
The burning monk photo became one of the first iconic news photos of the Vietnam War.
Browne died on Aug. 27, 2012 in New Hampshire at age 81.
Information for this article obtained from AP.org, and Wikipedia.
See my other two articles regarding the iconic photos of the “Napalm Girl” and “The Saigon street execution”:
https://cherrieswriter.wordpress.com/2015/08/03/the-story-behind-the-famous-saigon-execution-photo/
https://cherrieswriter.wordpress.com/2015/08/19/the-napalm-girl/
Thank you for taking the time to read this. Should you have a question or comment about this article, then scroll down to the comment section below to leave your response.
If you want to learn more about the Vietnam War and its Warriors, then subscribe to this blog and get notified by email or your feed reader every time a new story, picture, video or changes occur on this website – the button is located at the top right of this page.
I’ve also created a poll to help identify my website audience – before leaving, can you please click HERE and choose the one item best describing you. Thank you in advance!
Please learn more about the political status of Vietnam. It is nasty there. So many human rights activists, pro-freedom of religions, and pro-democracy activists have been killed and had their throats split by the communist state. Prostitutes, thieves and labor exploitation are what Vietnam is know for. When you are in Vietnam, don’t let tall buildings or luxurious shopping centers or resorts fool you. They are all owned by the members of the communist party. Liife in Vietnam is the worst in SE Asia…When you are there, look carefully and closely, you will see the truth.
LikeLike
Do not let the photos fool you without learning the truth behind them. These monks sided with Việt Cộng and the monk Thích Quảng Đức himself was drugged and taken to the spot in a van. He was not able to burn himself. Việt Cộng staged the whole thing by having other monks wall around him. These days in Vietnam, the monks have to be members of the communist party or their temples would be burned or torn down. All ‘communist’ temples in Vietnam worship Hochiminh, they trash all Buddha’s lectures and they even say that Hochiminh is more superior than Buddha. In 2015-2017, several people in Vietnam have set themselves on fire to protest China’s invasion and protest illegal land seizure carried out by the communist state but no media said a thing about it. Liên Trì, a historic temple, was torn down a couple of months ago by the communist state because the temple leader did not want to be involved in politics and did not want to a member of the communist party.
LikeLike
Im so surprised that after such a long time, there a foreigner recall the historic moment of our respected Thich Quang Duc. The moment that we could never forget but try to keep the pain sleeping. However, your post could help people understand deeply about the dark site of wars. No where in this world deserves being destroyed by wars. There is no good reason for war. Thank you.
LikeLike
It was a stupid war, Served no real purpose. It was L. B. J. Proving he was a badass. My he rot in hell.
LikeLike
Quite concur.
LikeLike
I understand, @fiftycaliber – thanks for your service, glad you made it home.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I now look at the VietNam war through different lenses than I have for the last 50 years.I have not mellowed or changed, I just think now as a Good Marine I got on a Plane and flew 10,000 miles from home. Applied what I was trained to do,and kill more of them than tried to kill me.I was fortunate to come home alive. I have tried to help as many of my Brothers and Sisters that did not come home Whole.I talk and reminisce about it at times when we are together, but honestly it is a time of suffering I wished I had not seen, but glad I did. Semper Fidelis 50/Cal.
LikeLiked by 1 person
@fiftycaliber – his death should have signaled the US something was seriously wrong – 80% of South Vietnam being Budhist – governed by a tiny, corrupt, Catholic elite. Instead, the CIA disposed of the two Diem brothers (a coup that ‘shocked’ Kennedy (probably because he noticed the similiarities with his own background and presidency….), replacing them with another corrupt president – also Catholic.
If the US ever had one opportunity to win the hearts and minds of the majority of the people, it was at that moment in time – not with medical aid and candy, for the next decade.
But the ‘best and brightest’ sent more troops to die, more bombs and more incompetent military leaders – all the while feeding the VC with new recruits, as the north promised land reforms and ‘democracy’ – only because DC never paid attention to a single burning monk…
LikeLiked by 2 people
I remember seeing this in the Stars & Stripes.Thought then as I do now,It is a waste of a life.They could do much more by being on earth and teaching people. What ever their religion, doing this to draw attention is wrong and proves nothing. Semper Fi, 50 Caliber
LikeLiked by 1 person
Weird people….
LikeLiked by 1 person
The Diems were such a bad lot. Shocking, the world leaders that are constantly inflicted upon the people. Just look at North Korea now.
Pretty much the same throughout history. So few admirable ones!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Do not let the photos fool you without learning the truth behind them. These monks sided with Việt Cộng and the monk Thích Quảng Đức himself was drugged and taken to the spot in a van. He was not able to burn himself. Việt Cộng staged the whole thing by having other monks wall around him. These days in Vietnam, the monks have to be members of the communist party or their temples would be burned or torn down. All ‘communist’ temples in Vietnam worship Hochiminh, they trash all Buddha’s lectures and they even say that Hochiminh is more superior than Buddha. In 2015-2017, several people in Vietnam have set themselves on fire to protest China’s invasion and protest illegal land seizure carried out by the communist state but no media said a thing about it. Liên Trì, a historic temple, was torn down a couple of months ago by the communist state because the temple leader did not want to be involved in politics and did not want to a member of the communist party.
LikeLike
Thank you for this John. It is good in my field to understand this kind of act……as always keep up the good work!!
LikeLiked by 1 person